Electric vs Hydraulic Home Lifts: The Definitive Guide

Drive comparison chart electric vs hydraulic
Choosing a home lift is more than a spec sheet decision. It is an investment in daily comfort, architectural sophistication and long-term property value.

Since 2006, Lift Shop has installed more than 10,000 lifts across Australia. We have seen every configuration, every constraint and every question. One persistent myth: electric is always superior. That is not necessarily true.

The right choice is not about trends. It is about fit. Fit for your space, your usage, and your future needs. That is why we provide both hydraulic and electric traction models—and guide every customer to what works best.

Our Full-Service Experience

Lift Shop delivers complete vertical transport systems: design drawings, builder liaison, safety coordination and seamless delivery—backed by our non-negotiable 8-year warranty. From 1 July 2025, every new lift includes up to 80,000-trip cover on parts and labour, provided serviced at least twice annually by our own technicians. This warranty is not optional, it is standard in metro areas (applies to all our hydraulic and electric lifts).

Our process ensures transparency with no hidden costs—your quote is your final price, including all standard installations without surprises. We also offer flexible planning and FastTrack installs from as little as 20 weeks.

Want to make an informed comparison? Read below or contact us—we’ll help without bias, tied only to what your project needs.

Hydraulic Lifts – Proven, Powerful, Practical

Hydraulic lifts employ a piston and sealed fluid reservoir that moves the cabin with controlled force. This method offers robust support and reliability, even in complex retrofit conditions.

Advantages

  • High load capacity and dependable performance for everyday use
  • Simpler mechanical structure enables easier servicing and fault resolution
  • Available in compact configurations with swing or sliding door options for restricted shafts
  • Preferred for low-rise, limited-use scenarios (up to 30 trips per hour) in private homes
  • Sealed system prevents oil smells or leaks, with free replacement if issues arise under regular service

Considerations

  • Operational noise from hydraulic pump (though still quiet in residential use)
  • Requires adjacent machine cabinet or deeper pit (~150-270 mm based on series)
  • Periodic servicing of fluid and seals is mandatory for compliance and warranty
  • In-Car Self Rescue (ICSR) is standard in all hydraulic models – allows users to move to a safe level and exit during power loss

Electric Traction Lifts – Quiet, Smooth, Efficient

Electric gearless traction lifts operate via cables, counterweights and high-precision motors, producing an exceptionally smooth and silent ride.

Advantages

  • Ultra-quiet operation (under 50 dB) enhances liveability in bedrooms and open-plan areas
  • Battery-backed in-car self rescue automatically lowers cabin safely in power failure
  • No hydraulic fluids—eliminates risk of leaks or environmental hazards
  • Low energy consumption, compatible with solar setups
  • Minimal pit depth and no machine room needed with machine room less (MRL) designs
  • Higher speeds and capacities for premium experiences
 

Considerations

  • Requires precise shaft and structural planning before installation
 

Safety and Support—Built In

  • In-Car Self Rescue (ICSR) for both hydraulic and electric models
  • Emergency phone system (GSM), power-failure sensing and auto-lowering routines
  • Full height light-curtain safety beams, overload detection and automatic fault alerts
  • Routine servicing by our trained technicians—free for the first three years, then custom-tailored plans
  • Industry leading 8-year warranty covering parts and labour for up to 80,000 trips, conditioned on service compliance
  • Three rescue options: external help via call, self-lowering on power failure, and ICSR for independent exit
 

Energy Use and Space Requirements

Hydraulic lifts draw power only when the pump runs, but the pump is active each trip. Electric lifts consume energy only during motion.

Hydraulic models typically require deeper pits (150-270 mm) and cabinet space. MRL electric models work with shallow pits and no machine room—making them ideal for modern builds and aesthetic integration.

 

Feature Comparison Table

FeatureElectric TractionHydraulic
Drive MechanismGeared or GearlessPiston & sealed hydraulic fluid
Noise LevelVery quiet (<50 dB)Moderate – pump whirr at each trip
Energy UsageLow consumption; solar readyPump use each cycle; higher running cost
Self RescueYes – battery backed – ICSRYes – ICSR standard in all models
Pit & Space RequirementMRL; Pit (190-270 mm), no machine roomPit (150-270 mm) & small cabinet
Servicing FrequencyTwice per yearTwice per year
Lifetime ValueHigh – low running & service costsGood – strong with regular upkeep
Capacity4-7 persons (350-450kg)4-6 persons (300-400kg)
Speed0.29-0.60 m/s0.30 m/s
Max LevelsUp to 6Up to 7

 

Installation Process for Home Lifts

Installing a home lift typically takes 4-6 months lead time. We handle everything from design to handover, including scaffold provision and builder coordination.

Key requirements: Pit depths from 150-270mm, headroom 2400-2950mm, single-phase power (25-32A). For future-proofing, consider building the shaft during home construction to reduce costs and avoid later engineering needs. Options include glass shafts or self-supporting steel structures.

Our FastTrack service can accelerate installs to 20 weeks. Visit our showrooms to see demos and plan your setup.

Maintenance and Servicing

Regular maintenance ensures longevity and warranty validity—twice annually by our technicians. First three years are free, with tailored plans thereafter.

For hydraulics, annual fluid and seal checks prevent issues. Electrics have fewer moving parts for minimal upkeep. Our 24/7 rescue service and low breakdown rates keep things reliable.

Why Choose Lift Shop?

Lift Shop is Australia’s only multinational home lift specialist. Established in 1996, we pioneered vertical movement solutions designed around style, safety and longevity—for over 28 years. Our lifts are exclusive to us, and our systems are backed by the largest home lift service team in the country.

We limit our workload to maintain quality. We design for longevity—not future service revenue. We believe real safety and real support require standards, not shortcuts. And that is backed by consistent five-star reviews and industry recognition.

Ready to discover the right lift fit for your home?
👉 Request a personalised quote
👉 Explore our Learn Resources
👉 Compare Residential Lifts